Learning-Centered Course Policies

Course Policies that Support Student Learning and Success

Because all instructors are required to include certain policies in their courses, we often approach policy writing as something that just has to be done and don’t give much thought to the purpose of those policies or how they should communicate to students. Some might even use policies from colleagues without considering whether they are a good fit. 

When we don’t give careful thought to the policies we design for courses, at best we miss an opportunity to guide our students’ learning; at worst, we risk confusing and alienating our students. Designing and writing policies with care helps us communicate what we value and gives us an opportunity to guide students’ learning. Well-crafted policies can also serve as a helpful beginning point for a conversation about what we hope our students will learn, how they can best do that learning, and how we will support them. 

This resource provides three big ideas to help you think about writing effective course policies along with explicated examples that can help you think about how you can create effective policies for your own courses. 

Big idea #1: Effective policies put students in control of their learning.

Course policies are often written as a set of rules along with a description of the punishments that follow from violation of those rules. These kinds of policies create a situation where the instructor’s role is to police students’ behavior and the students’ role is to stay out of trouble. Not only does this misdirect students’ energy and attention, it can also reduce their motivation and sense of autonomy because they feel that they are not fully in control of their own success or failure in a course.

A more productive approach is to write policies that put students in control of their own destiny by showing them that you have thought carefully about how they can be most successful in the course and how you can support them. Instead of writing policies that reward students for compliance and punish them for misbehavior, help students understand that your policies exist to help them be productive. This means explaining why you have put policies in place and how they will help their learning. 

For example, instead of an attendance policy where you take points off their grade for excessive absences, explain to students why attending classes will help them learn and be successful on assessments. Let them know that you will reach out to them if you become concerned about their attendance. The goal is to put students in the position to make informed decisions about attending class and yourself in the position to support them rather than punishing them. You’ve also provided a framework to help students make good choices about how to approach their work and given yourself space to step in when their choices put them in jeopardy. 

Big Idea #2: Effective policies demonstrate the value of the work students will do in the course.

It can be easy to forget that our policies have an important influence on the way that students see our courses. When we write policies that detail the rewards students will get for every piece of their work and the punishments they will receive when they don’t comply, we can accidentally send the message that the work they will do in the course has no intrinsic value. In fact, we can make them think that our course (or our discipline) is so painful and so lacking in value that we will have to force them to engage!

A more productive approach is to make sure that we are reinforcing the value and meaning of the work students will do in every aspect of the course syllabus—including the policies. Explain that you have made deliberate choices about the work they will do and have created policies that will support them in doing that work well.

For example, instead of telling students that they must put their cell phones away in class or they will lose participation points, explain that you will be doing exciting, engaging work in each class meeting that will require their full attention. Let them know that you’ll ask them to put their cell phones away so that they can focus on this work and their learning. Reinforce this in the first week of class by having students do work with research showing the negative effects of the presence of cell phones on their attention and their learning. This approach to a technology policy helps students see that you aren’t just asking them to put away their phones because you are trying to control their behavior, but instead it reinforces the idea that what happens in class has meaning and value that you don’t want them to miss.

Big idea #3: Effective policies demonstrate care for students and their learning.

Some course policies (and often entire syllabi) can have a cold, legalistic tone that immediately positions the instructor as enforcer of the rules and students as potential violators. When this is one of students’ first introductions to a course, they are likely to see the instructor as their adversary, not their advocate or guide. Moreover, policies that are rigid and don’t take into account the variety of challenges students may be facing can make students feel like they won’t be able to succeed in the course because they don’t see a supportive instructor there to guide them.

A more productive approach is to write policies using language that shows students you care about them and about their success. This requires you to think carefully about the substance of your policies first and then consider the tone that you use when communicating them. Explicitly acknowledge that you realize students may struggle at certain times in the course, and explain that you have written your policies to support them when they are struggling. 

For example, you might offer alternate due dates or rolling deadlines for assignments where you know you can manage your grading and feedback within those parameters. Alternately, you may give them a certain number of late passes that will allow them to submit specific assignments late. If it isn’t feasible to give flexible deadlines, you might give students the option to drop 1 or 2 low grades in the course so that they don’t lose motivation if they struggle with submitting an assignment or getting their work in on time.  

Course Policy Examples

Note that the policies below are designed as examples, not as templates. While you may feel free to borrow and adapt the language you see here, be sure to make adjustments that fit your specific course and your learning goals.

Sample Late Work Policy

Final drafts are considered due at the time and date specified on the Course Schedule. While in an ideal world I would expect to receive all of your essays at the due date and time, I realize that my scheduling of these assignments sometimes coincides with other responsibilities—both academic and personal—that you are obligated to fulfill. For that reason, you have a “late pass” for late submission of one of the four essays that you will be writing for the course. You can use this pass to turn in an essay no more than two class meetings (1 calendar week) late. Because you already have this built-in extension for one essay, there is no need to ask for additional extensions on the essays unless there are serious extenuating circumstances.

How does this policy exemplify the big ideas?

This policy emphasizes student autonomy. Students are given an explicit choice about their approach to a course assignment, within specific limits. This means that the decision about submitting a late assignment is in their hands, not the instructor’s. They don’t have to ask for permission, which may be intimidating for some students. The policy also puts responsibility on the students, requiring them to be strategic and to make careful use of the option for flexibility, but it also demonstrates that the instructor cares about the students and understands the challenges they may face. 

Sample Attendance Policy

I have designed exciting, important work for us to do during class every day, and this in-class work is the key to your success in this course. While attendance itself is not graded, you will do work every day in class that is designed to help you practice and get the feedback you need to do well on the course assignments. Most importantly, I want you to learn in this class, so missing our class meetings means less time for your learning and fewer opportunities for me to support you with feedback. If you miss multiple classes in a row, I will email you to check in and help you make a plan for more consistent attendance.

How does this policy exemplify the big ideas?

This policy emphasizes the value of the work students do in class. The language is positive, and the policy itself shows that the instructor has given thought to designing engaging class meetings. It also demonstrates that the instructor cares about the students themselves and expresses concern for their success and well-being. 

Sample Makeup Work Policy

(adapted from Christine Harrington)

Being able to meet deadlines and juggle many tasks is an important career and life skill. Thus, it is expected that you will complete all quizzes and exams according to the schedule. However, I know that life happens! If you find yourself unable to attend class on a quiz or exam day, please discuss this with me in advance, if possible, so that we can make arrangements for you to complete your work. If an emergency situation arises and you can’t talk to me in advance, please reach out as soon as possible and we will make a plan to help you catch up.

How does this policy exemplify the big ideas?

This policy emphasizes care for students. The instructor acknowledges that students have complicated lives and places value of students’ well-being above the value of a set deadline. It puts the instructor in the role of helpful guide, but at the same time, it requires that students take responsibility for communicating with the instructor to arrange the makeup work.

Sample AI Policy

We are all tempted to take shortcuts when we’re stressed and things feel overwhelming, but taking those shortcuts won’t help you learn how to research and write. Most importantly, these skills are not just useful in this course or in your academic studies, but they are skills that you will be able to use in all aspects of your life. The assignments in this course are broken into smaller pieces of writing, so you will have a lot of opportunities to improve before final assignments are graded. You will receive feedback from me and your peers to help you improve, and I will help you use AI for feedback on your writing. You will have a lot of support throughout the semester! If you’re feeling anxious and tempted to use AI, come to me and we can make a plan for your success. 

If I notice anything in your work that concerns me, I will reach out to schedule a meeting with you. At that meeting, we will look at your work together and make sure that you are using AI in ways that facilitate your learning and don’t short circuit it. I may ask you to revise or rewrite your work if we decide that will help you reach the learning goals in this course.

How does this policy exemplify the big ideas?

This policy emphasizes care for students and their learning. Not only does the instructor acknowledge the temptations that students face, but they also remind students that they will be doing work throughout the course that will prepare them to complete assignments on their own without inappropriate use of AI. This policy also specifically addresses the connection between the policy and the discipline students are learning (history), which reminds students that the instructor values the development of their thinking as historians.

Sample Classroom Technology Policy

(adapted from James M. Lang)

We are all challenged these days by the ways in which our digital devices—including laptops, tablets, and phones—can steal our attention away from our immediate surroundings. In this class, we will have a technology policy that is designed to support your attention to one another and to the course material. I have developed this policy for three reasons: (1) A significant body of research demonstrates that when students engage in off-task behavior on their devices, it hurts the learning of the peers sitting near them. (2) This class depends upon everyone’s active engagement. If you are focused on your device, instead of our work, you are depriving the entire class of your ideas and questions—both of which we all want to hear. Your attention contributes to all of our learning. (3) Finally, since so much of the course depends upon discussion, I want to make sure that we all show respect for one another by listening to each other. We all have likely had the demoralizing experience of trying to speak with someone who was focused on their phone, and feeling hurt by their lack of attention to us. In this class I want us to respect everyone’s voices by being present and listening to each other.

In order to achieve all of these objectives, here are the guidelines for using electronic devices in class:

  1. You may use laptops to read the texts and take notes in the course as you wish and as needed. If you use a laptop, close any tabs that are not related to the course. Remember, off-task behaviors can hurt the learning of your peers.
  2. You may have your phones out on your desk, but keep them face down so you are not continually seeing new notifications that steal away your attention. Those continued flashes of light have been engineered to hijack your attention, and can hurt both your learning and the learning of your peers. 
  3. There will be times in class when I want everyone to put their devices away and focus on some activity: a quick writing exercise, a discussion circle, a worksheet. In those activities, we will all be device free.
  4. Finally, in order to show to everyone that we are listening respectfully to one another, please remove any air pods or ear buds at the start of class. 

How does this policy exemplify the big ideas?

This policy emphasizes the value of the work students will do in class, in particular the interactions they will have with each other. It also demonstrates that the instructor has thought carefully not only about structuring an engaging and interactive learning environment for students, but also how students can best make use of that environment. 

Increase value by have students co-create course policies

If we really want to change the way students see our policies, one of the best things we can do is to give them a voice. It isn’t feasible (or wise) to have students create the entire syllabus, but you can give them the opportunity to share their thinking and to make choices about how they want to work in your course. This approach gives students a sense of autonomy and control, invites them to identify the value of their work, and demonstrates that you care about their success and their perspective. 

For example, you might ask students to evaluate two possible policies regarding cell phone usage (which you have written) and decide which one they think will be most productive and why. (This can be especially productive after they have explored some of the research on personal devices and attention!) You may also give them the option to make some revisions or propose an adapted policy. The conversation will be helpful because students will have to consider which policy will best support their learning, and they will be more likely to abide by the policy the class chooses because they had the opportunity to contribute to its development.

Resources

  • Bowen, J. A., & Watson, C. E. (2024). Teaching with AI: A Practical Guide to a New Era of Human Learning. Johns Hopkins University Press.
  • Center for the Advancement of Teaching, Learning, and Online Education. (n.d.). How can we design and write course policies about AI use that focus on student learning? University at Albany-SUNY.
  • Center for the Advancement of Teaching, Learning, and Online Education. (n.d.). Preventing and responding to digital distractions. University at Albany-SUNY.
  • Graduate School. (n.d.). Course changes and syllabus guide. University at Albany-SUNY.
  • Harrington, C., & Thomas, M. (2018). Designing a motivating syllabus. Stylus Publishing.
  • Lang, J. M. (2020). Distracted: Why students can’t focus and what you can do about it. Basic Books.
  • Lovett, M., Bridges, M. W., DiPietro, M., Ambrose, S. A., & Norman, M. K. (2023). What motivates students to learn? In How learning works: Seven research-based principles for smart teaching (pp. 84-105). Jossey-Bass.
  • Undergraduate Education. (n.d.). Undergraduate academic regulations. University at Albany-SUNY.