Univ @ Albany


feedback

New York State Consolidated Laws

Public Health Law

ARTICLE 27-F

HIV AND AIDS RELATED INFORMATION




Section 2780. Definitions.



        2781. HIV related testing.



        2782. Confidentiality and disclosure.



        2783. Penalties; immunities.



        2784. Applicability  to  insurance  institutions  and  insurance



                support organizations.



        2785. Court  authorization  for  disclosure  of confidential HIV



                related information.



        2785-a. Court order for HIV related testing in certain cases.



        2786. Rules and regulations; forms; report.



        2787. Separability.




   S 2780. Definitions.  As used in this article, the following terms shall



have the following meanings:



  1.  "AIDS"  means  acquired immune deficiency syndrome, as may be defined



from time to time by the centers for disease control of the  United  States



public health service.



  2.  "HIV infection" means infection with the human immunodeficiency virus



or any other related virus identified as  a  probable  causative  agent  of



AIDS.



  3. "HIV related illness" means any illness that may result from or may be



associated with HIV infection.



  4.  "HIV  related  test" means any laboratory test or series of tests for



any virus, antibody, antigen or etiologic agent whatsoever thought to cause



or to indicate the presence of AIDS.



  5.  "Capacity  to  consent"  means  an  individual`s  ability, determined



without regard to the individual`s age, to understand  and  appreciate  the



nature  and  consequences  of a proposed health care service, treatment, or



procedure,  or  of  a  proposed  disclosure  of  confidential  HIV  related



information,  as  the  case  may  be,  and  to  make  an  informed decision



concerning the service, treatment, procedure or disclosure.



  6.  "Protected  individual"  means  a person who is the subject of an HIV



related test or who has been diagnosed as having HIV infection, AIDS or HIV



related illness.



  7.  "Confidential  HIV related information" means any information, in the



possession of a person who provides one or more health or  social  services



or  who  obtains  the information pursuant to a release of confidential HIV



related information, concerning whether an individual has been the  subject



of  an HIV related test, or has HIV infection, HIV related illness or AIDS,



or information which identifies or reasonably could identify an  individual



as  having one or more of such conditions, including information pertaining



to such individual`s contacts.



  8.  "Health  or  social  service"  means  any  public  or  private  care,



treatment, clinical laboratory test, counseling or educational service  for



adults or children, and acute, chronic, custodial, residential, outpatient,



home or other health care provided pursuant to this chapter or  the  social



services  law;  public  assistance or care as defined in article one of the



social services law; employment-related services, housing services,  foster



care,  shelter,  protective  services,  day  care,  or  preventive services



provided pursuant to the social services law;  services  for  the  mentally



disabled  as  defined  in  article one of the mental hygiene law; probation



services,  provided  pursuant  to  articles  twelve  and  twelve-A  of  the



executive  law;  parole  services, provided pursuant to article twelve-B of



the  executive  law;  correctional  services,  provided  pursuant  to   the



correction  law; detention and rehabilitative services provided pursuant to



article nineteen-G of the executive law; and the activities of  the  health



care  worker  HIV/HBV advisory panel pursuant to article twenty-seven-DD of



this chapter.



  9.  "Release  of  confidential  HIV  related information" means a written



authorization for disclosure of confidential HIV related information  which



is signed by the protected individual, or if the protected individual lacks



capacity to consent, a person authorized pursuant  to  law  to  consent  to



health  care  for  the  individual.  Such  release shall be dated and shall



specify to whom disclosure is authorized, the purpose for  such  disclosure



and  the time period during which the release is to be effective. A general



authorization for the release of medical or other information shall not  be



construed as a release of confidential HIV related information, unless such



authorization  specifically  indicates  its  dual  purpose  as  a   general



authorization  and  an  authorization  for  the release of confidential HIV



related information and complies with the requirements of this subdivision.



  10.  "Contact" means an identified spouse or sex partner of the protected



individual or a person identified as having shared  hypodermic  needles  or



syringes with the protected individual.



  11. "Person" includes any natural person, partnership, association, joint



venture, trust, public or private corporation, or state or local government



agency.



  12. "Health facility" means a hospital as defined in section two thousand



eight hundred one of this chapter, blood bank, blood  center,  sperm  bank,



organ  or  tissue  bank, clinical laboratory, or facility providing care or



treatment to persons with a mental disability as defined in article one  of



the mental hygiene law.



  13.  "Health  care  provider"  means  any  physician,  nurse, provider of



services for the mentally disabled as defined in article one of the  mental



hygiene  law,  or  other  person  involved  in  providing medical, nursing,



counseling, or other health care or mental health service, including  those



associated with, or under contract to, a health maintenance organization or



medical services plan.



  14.   "Child" means any protected individual actually or apparently under



eighteen years of age.



  15.   "Authorized  agency"  means  any  agency  defined  by section three



hundred seventy-one of the social services law and,  for  the  purposes  of



this  article,  shall  include  such corporations incorporated or organized



under the laws of the state as may  be  specifically  authorized  by  their



certificates  of  incorporation  to  receive  children  for the purposes of



adoption or foster care.



  16.   "Insurance   institution"   means   any  corporation,  association,



partnership, reciprocal exchange, interinsurer, fraternal benefits society,



agent,  broker  or  other  entity including, but not limited to, any health



maintenance organization, medical service plan, or hospital plan which: (a)



is  engaged  in  the  business  of  insurance; (b) provides health services



coverage plans; or (c) provides benefits under,  administers,  or  provides



services  for,  an  employee  welfare  benefit plan as defined in 29 U.S.C.



1002(1).



  17.  "Insurance  support  organization"  means  any  person who regularly



engages, in whole or in part, in the practice of assembling  or  collecting



information  about natural persons for the primary purpose of providing the



information  to  an  insurance  institution  for  insurance   transactions,



including: (a) the furnishing of consumer reports or investigative consumer



reports to an  insurance  instititution  for  use  in  connection  with  an



insurance  transaction;  or (b) the collection of personal information from



insurance institutions or other insurance  support  organizations  for  the



purpose  of  detecting  or preventing fraud, material misrepresentation, or



material  non-disclosure  in  connection  with  insurance  underwriting  or



insurance  claim  activity.  The  following persons shall not be considered



"insurance-support  organizations"  for  the  purposes  of  this   article:



government  institutions,  insurance  institutions,  health  facilities and



health care providers.



 


   S  2781.  HIV related testing. 1. Except as provided in section three



thousand one hundred twenty-one of the civil practice law and rules,  or



unless  otherwise  specifically  authorized  or  required  by a state or



federal law, no person shall order the performance  of  an  HIV  related



test  without  first  receiving  the  written,  informed  consent of the



subject of the test who has capacity to consent  or,  when  the  subject



lacks  capacity  to  consent,  of a person authorized pursuant to law to



consent to health care for such individual. A physician or other  person



authorized  pursuant  to  law to order the performance of an HIV related



test shall certify, in the order for the performance of an  HIV  related



test,  that  informed consent required by this section has been received



prior to ordering such test by a laboratory or other facility.



  2.  Informed  consent  to  an  HIV  related  test  shall  consist of a



statement signed by the subject of the test who has capacity to  consent



or,  when  the subject lacks capacity to consent, by a person authorized



pursuant to law to consent to health care for the subject which includes



at least the following:



  (a)  an explanation of the test, including its purpose, the meaning of



its  results,  and  the  benefits  of  early   diagnosis   and   medical



intervention; and



  (b)  an  explanation  of the procedures to be followed, including that



the test is voluntary, that consent may be withdrawn at any time, and  a



statement advising the subject that anonymous testing is available; and



  (c)   an  explanation  of  the  confidentiality  protections  afforded



confidential HIV related information under this article,  including  the



circumstances  under  which and classes of persons to whom disclosure of



such information may be required, authorized  or  permitted  under  this



article or in accordance with other provisions of law or regulation.



  3.  Prior  to  the  execution  of a written informed consent, a person



ordering the performance of an HIV related test  shall  provide  to  the



subject  of  an  HIV  related  test or, if the subject lacks capacity to



consent, to a person authorized pursuant to law  to  consent  to  health



care  for  the  subject,  an  explanation  of the nature of AIDS and HIV



related  illness,  information  about   discrimination   problems   that



disclosure  of the test result could cause and legal protections against



such discrimination, and information about behavior known to pose  risks



for transmission and contraction of HIV infection.



  4.  A person authorized pursuant to law to order the performance of an



HIV related test shall provide  to  the  person  seeking  such  test  an



opportunity to remain anonymous and to provide written, informed consent



through use of a coded system with no linking of individual identity  to



the  test  request  or  results.  A  health  care  provider  who  is not



authorized by the commissioner  to  provide  HIV  related  tests  on  an



anonymous basis shall refer a person who requests an anonymous test to a



test site which does provide anonymous testing. The provisions  of  this



subdivision  shall  not  apply  to  a  health care provider ordering the



performance of an  HIV  related  test  on  an  individual  proposed  for



insurance coverage.



  5.  At the time of communicating the test result to the subject of the



test, a person ordering the performance of an  HIV  related  test  shall



provide  the  subject  of  the test or, if the subject lacks capacity to



consent, the person authorized pursuant to law to consent to health care



for  the  subject  with  counseling or referrals for counseling: (a) for



coping with the emotional  consequences  of  learning  the  result;  (b)



regarding  the  discrimination  problems  that  disclosure of the result



could  cause;  (c)  for  behavior  change  to  prevent  transmission  or



contraction  of  HIV  infection;  (d) to inform such person of available



medical treatments; and (e) regarding the test subject`s need to  notify



his or her contacts.



  6.  The  provisions of this section shall not apply to the performance



of an HIV related test:



  (a)  by  a  health care provider or health facility in relation to the



procuring, processing, distributing or use of a human body  or  a  human



body  part,  including  organs,  tissues,  eyes, bones, arteries, blood,



semen, or other body fluids, for use in medical research or therapy,  or



for  transplantation  to  individuals  provided, however, that where the



test results are communicated to the subject, post-test  counseling,  as



described  in  subdivision  five  of  this section, shall nonetheless be



required; or



  (b)  for  the  purpose  of  research  if the testing is performed in a



manner by which the identity of the test subject is not  known  and  may



not be retrieved by the researcher; or



  (c) on a deceased person, when such test is conducted to determine the



cause of death or for epidemiological purposes.



  (d)  conducted  pursuant  to  section  twenty-five  hundred-f  of this



chapter.



 


  S  2782.  Confidentiality and disclosure.   1. No person who obtains



confidential HIV related information in the course  of  providing  any



health  or social service or pursuant to a release of confidential HIV



related information may disclose or  be  compelled  to  disclose  such



information, except to the following:



  (a) the protected individual or, when the protected individual lacks



capacity to consent, a person authorized pursuant to law to consent to



health care for the individual;



  (b)  any  person  to  whom  disclosure  is  authorized pursuant to a



release of confidential HIV related information;



  (c) an agent or  employee  of  a  health  facility  or  health  care



provider  if  (1) the agent or employee is permitted to access medical



records, (2) the health facility or health  care  provider  itself  is



authorized to obtain the HIV related information, and (3) the agent or



employee   provides  health  care  to  the  protected  individual,  or



maintains or processes medical records for billing or reimbursement;



  (d) a health care provider or health facility when knowledge of  the



HIV  related  information  is necessary to provide appropriate care or



treatment to the protected individual or a child of the individual;



  (e) a health facility or health care provider, in  relation  to  the



procurement,  processing,  distributing  or  use  of a human body or a



human body part, including organs,  tissues,  eyes,  bones,  arteries,



blood,  semen,  or  other  body  fluids, for use in medical education,



research, therapy, or for transplantation to individuals;



  (f) health facility staff committees or accreditation  or  oversight



review  organizations  authorized  to access medical records; provided



that such committees or organizations may only  disclose  confidential



HIV  related  information:  (1)  back to the facility or provider of a



health or social service; (2) to carry out the monitoring, evaluation,



or service review for which it was obtained;  or  (3)  to  a  federal,



state  or  local  government agency for the purposes of and subject to



the conditions provided in subdivision six of this section;



  (g) a federal, state, county  or  local  health  officer  when  such



disclosure is mandated by federal or state law;



  (h)  an authorized agency in connection with foster care or adoption



of a child.  Such  agency  shall  be  authorized  to  redisclose  such



information  only  pursuant  to this article or in accordance with the



provisions of subdivision eight of section three  hundred  seventy-two



and section three hundred seventy-three-a of the social services law;



  (i)  third party reimbursers or their agents to the extent necessary



to reimburse health care providers for health services; provided that,



where necessary,  an  otherwise  appropriate  authorization  for  such



disclosure has been secured by the provider;



  (j)  an  insurance institution, for other than the purpose set forth



in  paragraph  (i)  of  this  subdivision,  provided   the   insurance



institution  secures  a dated and written authorization that indicates



that health care providers, health facilities, insurance institutions,



and other persons are authorized to  disclose  information  about  the



protected  individual,  the nature of the information to be disclosed,



the purposes for which the information is to be disclosed and which is



signed  by:  (1)  the  protected  individual;  (2)  if  the  protected



individual lacks the capacity to consent, such other person authorized



pursuant  to  law  to  consent  for  such  individual;  or  (3) if the



protected individual is deceased,  the  beneficiary  or  claimant  for



benefits  under  an  insurance  policy,  a health services plan, or an



employee welfare  benefit  plan  as  defined  in  29  U.S.C.  1002(1),



covering such protected individual;



  (k) any person to whom disclosure is ordered by a court of competent



jurisdiction  pursuant  to section twenty-seven hundred eighty-five of



this article;



  (l) an employee or agent of the division of  parole,  in  accordance



with  paragraph (a) of subdivision two of section twenty-seven hundred



eighty-six of this article, to the extent the  employee  or  agent  is



authorized  to  access records containing such information in order to



carry out the division`s functions, powers and duties with respect  to



the protected individual, pursuant to section two hundred fifty-nine-a



of the executive law;



  (m)   an  employee  or  agent  of  the  division  of  probation  and



correctional  alternatives  or  any  local  probation  department,  in



accordance   with   paragraph   (a)  of  subdivision  two  of  section



twenty-seven hundred eighty-six of this article,  to  the  extent  the



employee  or  agent  is  authorized  to access records containing such



information in order to  carry  out  the  division`s  or  department`s



functions, powers and duties with respect to the protected individual,



pursuant to articles twelve and twelve-A of the executive law;



  (n)  a  medical director of a local correctional facility as defined



in section forty of the correction law, in accordance  with  paragraph



(a)  of  subdivision two of section twenty-seven hundred eighty-six of



this article, to the extent the  medical  director  is  authorized  to



access  records  containing such information in order to carry out his



or her functions, powers and duties  with  respect  to  the  protected



individual; or



  (o)  an  employee  or  agent  of  the  commission  of correction, in



accordance  with  paragraph  (a)  of  subdivision   two   of   section



twenty-seven  hundred  eighty-six  of  this article, to the extent the



employee or agent is authorized  to  access  records  containing  such



information  in  order to carry out the commission`s functions, powers



and duties with respect  to  the  protected  individual,  pursuant  to



article three of the correction law.



  (p)  a  law guardian, appointed to represent a minor pursuant to the



social  services  law  or  the  family  court  act,  with  respect  to



confidential HIV related information relating to the minor and for the



purpose  of  representing  the minor. If the minor has the capacity to



consent, the law guardian may not redisclose confidential HIV  related



information  without  the  minor`s  permission.  If  the  minor  lacks



capacity to consent, the law guardian may redisclose confidential  HIV



related  information  for  the sole purpose of representing the minor.



This paragraph shall not limit a law guardian`s ability to seek relief



under section twenty-seven hundred eighty-five of this chapter.



  2. A state, county or local health officer may disclose confidential



HIV related information when:



  (a) disclosure is specifically authorized or required by federal  or



state law; or



  (b)  disclosure  is  made  pursuant to a release of confidential HIV



related information; or



  (c) disclosure is requested by a physician pursuant  to  subdivision



four of this section; or



  (d)  disclosure  is  authorized  by  court  order  pursuant  to  the



provisions  of  section  twenty-seven  hundred  eighty-five  of   this



article.



  3.  No  person to whom confidential HIV related information has been



disclosed pursuant to this article shall disclose the  information  to



another  person  except  as  authorized  by  this  article,  provided,



however, that the provisions of this subdivision shall not apply:



  (a) to the protected individual; or



  (b) to a natural person who is authorized pursuant to law to consent



to health care for the protected individual; or



  (c)  to a protected individual`s foster parent as defined in section



three hundred seventy-one of the social services law  and  subject  to



regulations  promulgated  pursuant to paragraph (a) of subdivision two



of section twenty-seven hundred eighty-six of this  article,  for  the



purpose  of  providing care, treatment or supervision of the protected



individual; or



  (d) a prospective adoptive parent  as  specified  in  section  three



hundred  seventy-three-a  of  the  social  services law and subject to



regulations promulgated pursuant to paragraph (a) of  subdivision  two



of section twenty-seven hundred eighty-six of this article with whom a



child who is the protected individual has been placed for adoption; or



  (e)  to  a  relative  or  other person legally responsible to whom a



child who is the protected individual is to be  placed  or  discharged



pursuant to section ten hundred seventeen or ten hundred fifty-five of



the  family  court act and subject to regulations promulgated pursuant



to paragraph (a) of subdivision two of  section  twenty-seven  hundred



eighty-six  of  this  article,  for  the  purpose  of  providing care,



treatment or supervision of the protected individual.



  4. (a) A physician may disclose confidential HIV related information



under the following conditions:



  (1) disclosure is made to a contact or to a  public  health  officer



for the purpose of making the disclosure to said contact; and



  (2)  the  physician  reasonably  believes  disclosure  is  medically



appropriate and there is  a  significant  risk  of  infection  to  the



contact; and



  (3)  the  physician has counseled the protected individual regarding



the need to notify the contact, and the physician reasonably  believes



the protected individual will not inform the contact; and



  (4)  the  physician  has informed the protected individual of his or



her intent to make such disclosure to a  contact  and  has  given  the



protected  individual  the  opportunity  to express a preference as to



whether disclosure should be made by the physician directly  or  to  a



public  health  officer  for  the purpose of said disclosure.   If the



protected individual expresses a preference for disclosure by a public



health officer or by the physician, the  physician  shall  honor  such



preference.



  (b)  When  making  such  disclosures to the contact,the physician or



public  health  officer  shall  provide  or  make  referrals  for  the



provision  of the appropriate medical advice and counseling for coping



with the emotional consequences of learning the  information  and  for



changing  behavior  to  prevent  transmission  or  contraction  of HIV



infection. The physician or public health officer shall  not  disclose



the  identity of the protected individual or the identity of any other



contact. A physician or public health officer  making  a  notification



pursuant  to  this  subdivision  shall make such disclosure in person,



except where circumstances reasonably prevent doing so.



  (c) A physician or public health officer shall have no obligation to



identify or locate any contact.



  (d) A physician may, upon the  consent  of  a  parent  or  guardian,



disclose  confidential  HIV related information to a state, county, or



local health officer for the purpose of reviewing the medical  history



of a child to determine the fitness of the child to attend school.



  (e)  A  physician  may disclose confidential HIV related information



pertaining to a  protected  individual  to  a  person  (known  to  the



physician)  authorized pursuant to law to consent to health care for a



protected individual when the physician reasonably believes that:  (1)



disclosure  is medically necessary in order to provide timely care and



treatment for the protected  individual;  and  (2)  after  appropriate



counseling   as  to  the  need  for  such  disclosure,  the  protected



individual will not inform a person authorized by law  to  consent  to



health care; provided, however, that the physician shall not make such



disclosure  if,  in  the judgment of the physician: (A) the disclosure



would not be in the best interest of the protected individual; or  (B)



the  protected  individual is authorized pursuant to law to consent to



such care and treatment. Any decision or action by a  physician  under



this  paragraph,  and  the  basis  therefor,  shall be recorded in the



protected individual`s medical record.



  5. (a) Whenever disclosure of confidential HIV  related  information



is made pursuant to this article, except for disclosures made pursuant



to  paragraph  (a) of subdivision one of this section or paragraph (a)



or (e) of subdivision four of this section, such disclosure  shall  be



accompanied  or  followed by a statement in writing which includes the



following or substantially similar  language:  "This  information  has



been disclosed to you from confidential records which are protected by



state  law. State law prohibits you from making any further disclosure



of this information without the specific written consent of the person



to  whom  it  pertains,  or  as  otherwise  permitted  by   law.   Any



unauthorized  further  disclosure in violation of state law may result



in a fine or jail sentence or both. A general  authorization  for  the



release   of   medical   or   other   information  is  NOT  sufficient



authorization for further disclosure." An  oral  disclosure  shall  be



accompanied or followed by such a notice within ten days.



  (b)  Except  for  disclosures  made  pursuant  to  paragraph  (c) of



subdivision one of this section, or to persons  reviewing  information



or  records  in the ordinary course of ensuring that a health facility



is in compliance with applicable quality  of  care  standards  or  any



other  authorized  program  evaluation,  program monitoring or service



review, or to governmental agents requiring information necessary  for



payments  to  be  made  on  behalf  of patients or clients pursuant to



contract or in accordance to law, a notation of all  such  disclosures



shall  be  placed in the medical record of a protected individual, who



shall be informed of such disclosures upon request; provided, however,



that for disclosures made to insurance institutions  such  a  notation



need only be entered at the time the disclosure is first made.



  6.  (a)  The  provisions  of  this  subdivision  shall apply where a



provider of a health or  social  service  possesses  confidential  HIV



related  information relating to individuals who are recipients of the



service, and a federal, state or local government agency supervises or



monitors the provider or  administers  the  program  under  which  the



service is provided.



  (b)  Confidential HIV related information relating to a recipient of



such  service  may  be  disclosed  in  accordance   with   regulations



promulgated  pursuant  to  paragraph (a) of subdivision two of section



twenty-seven hundred eighty-six  of  this  article  to  an  authorized



employee  or  agent  of  such  provider  or  government  agency,  when



reasonably necessary for such supervision, monitoring, administration,



or provision of such service. The term "authorized employee or agent",



as  used  in this subdivision shall only include any employee or agent



who would, in the ordinary course  of  business  of  the  provider  or



government  agency,  have  access  to records relating to the care of,



treatment of, or provision of  a  health  or  social  service  to  the



protected individual.



  7.  Nothing  in  this  section  shall  limit  a person`s or agency`s



responsibility or authority to  report,  investigate,  or  redisclose,



child   protective   and  adult  protective  services  information  in



accordance with title six of article six and titles  one  and  two  of



article  nine-B  of  the social services law, or to provide or monitor



the provision of child and adult protective or preventive services.



  8. Confidential HIV related information shall  be  recorded  in  the



medical  record  of  the protected individual.  The provisions of this



section shall not prohibit the listing of acquired  immune  deficiency



syndrome,  HIV  related  illness  or HIV infection in a certificate of



death, autopsy  report  or  related  documents  prepared  pursuant  to



article   forty-one   of   this  chapter  or  other  applicable  laws,



ordinances, rules or regulations  relating  to  the  documentation  of



cause  of  death,  nor  shall  this section be construed to modify any



laws, ordinances, rules or regulations relative  to  access  to  death



certificates,  autopsy  reports or such other related documents. Under



no  circumstances  shall  confidential  HIV  related  information   be



disclosable  pursuant  to  article  six  of  the  public officers law.



Notwithstanding the foregoing, confidential HIV  information  obtained



pursuant  to  section  390.15 of the criminal procedure law or section



347.1 of the family court act by either court order or consent of  the



protected  individual  shall  not be recorded in the medical record of



the protected individual unless he or she consents to the recording of



such information  in  a  written  statement  containing  the  relevant



information specified in subdivision two of section two thousand seven



hundred eighty-one of this article.



  9.  Confidential HIV related information shall be disclosed upon the



request of the health care worker HIV/HBV advisory panel,  established



pursuant  to  article twenty-seven-DD of this chapter, to the panel or



its designee only when reasonably necessary for the  evaluation  of  a



worker who has voluntarily sought the panel`s review.



 


   S 2783. Penalties; immunities. 1. Any person who shall:



  (a) perform, or permit or procure the performance of, an HIV related test



in violation of section twenty-seven hundred eighty-one of this article; or



  (b)   disclose,  or  compel  another  person  to disclose, or procure the



disclosure of, confidential HIV related information in violation of section



twenty-seven  hundred  eighty-two  of  this  article; shall be subject to a



civil penalty not to exceed five  thousand  dollars  for  each  occurrence.



Such penalty may be recovered in the same manner as the penalty provided in



section twelve of this chapter.



  2.  Any person who willfully commits an act enumerated in subdivision one



of this section shall be  guilty  of  a  misdemeanor  and  subject  to  the



penalties provided in section twelve-b of this chapter.



  3. There shall be no criminal sanction or civil liability on the part of,



and no cause of action for damages shall arise against any physician or his



or  her employer, or health facility or health care provider with which the



physician is associated, or public health officer, solely on account of:



  (a)   the  failure  to disclose confidential HIV related information to a



contact or person authorized pursuant to law to consent to health care  for



a protected individual; or



  (b)   the disclosure of confidential HIV related information to a contact



or person authorized pursuant to law  to  consent  to  health  care  for  a



protected  individual,  when  carried out in good faith and without malice,



and in compliance with this article; or



  (c)   the  disclosure  of  confidential  HIV  related  information to any



person, agency, or officer authorized to  receive  such  information,  when



carried  out  in  good faith and without malice, and in compliance with the



provisions of this article.



  4.   Any cause of action to recover damages based on a failure to provide



information, explanations, or  counseling  prior  to  the  execution  of  a



written  informed  consent,  or  based on a lack of informed consent in the



ordering or performance of an HIV related test in violation of this article



shall  be  governed by the provisions of section two thousand eight hundred



five-d of this chapter.



 


   S  2784.   Applicability to insurance institutions and insurance support



organizations.  Except  for  disclosure  to  third  party  reimbursers  and



insurance  institutions  pursuant  to paragraphs (i) and (j) of subdivision



one of section twenty-seven hundred eighty-two of this article  and  except



for  disclosures  pursuant  to  section twenty-seven hundred eighty-five of



this article, the provisions of this article shall not apply  to  insurance



institutions  and  insurance support organizations, except that health care



providers associated  with  or  under  contract  to  a  health  maintenance



organization  or  other  medical  services  plan  shall  be  subject to the



provisions of this article.



 


   S  2785.  Court authorization for disclosure of confidential HIV related



information.  1.  Notwithstanding any other  provision  of  law,  no  court



shall  issue  an  order  for  the  disclosure  of  confidential HIV related



information,  except  a  court  of  record  of  competent  jurisdiction  in



accordance with the provisions of this section.



  2.  A court may grant an order for disclosure of confidential HIV related



information upon an  application  showing:   (a)   a  compelling  need  for



disclosure  of  the information for the adjudication of a criminal or civil



proceeding; (b)  a clear and imminent danger to an individual whose life or



health  may  unknowingly be at significant risk as a result of contact with



the individual to whom the information pertains; (c)  upon application of a



state,  county  or local health officer, a clear and imminent danger to the



public health; or (d) that  the  applicant  is  lawfully  entitled  to  the



disclosure  and  the  disclosure  is consistent with the provisions of this



article.



  3.  Upon  receiving  an  application  for an order authorizing disclosure



pursuant to this section, the court shall enter an order directing that all



pleadings,  papers,  affidavits, judgments, orders of the court, briefs and



memoranda of law which are part of the application or the decision thereon,



be  sealed  and  not  made  available  to  any person, except to the extent



necessary to conduct any proceedings in connection with  the  determination



of whether to grant or deny the application, including any appeal.  Such an



order shall further direct that all subsequent  proceedings  in  connection



with  the  application shall be conducted in camera, and, where appropriate



to  prevent  the  unauthorized  disclosure  of  confidential  HIV   related



information,  that  any pleadings, papers, affidavits, judgments, orders of



the court, briefs and memoranda of law which are part of the application or



the  decision  thereon not state the name of the individual concerning whom



confidential HIV related information is sought.



  4.    (a)   The  individual  concerning  whom  confidential  HIV  related



information  is  sought  and  any   person   holding   records   concerning



confidential  HIV  related information from whom disclosure is sought shall



be given adequate notice of such application in a  manner  which  will  not



disclose  to  any other person the identity of the individual, and shall be



afforded an opportunity to file a written response to the  application,  or



to  appear  in  person for the limited purpose of providing evidence on the



statutory criteria for the issuance of an order pursuant to this section.



  (b)   The court may grant an order without such notice and opportunity to



be heard, where an ex parte application by a public  health  officer  shows



that  a clear and imminent danger to an individual whose life or health may



unknowingly be at risk requires an immediate order.



  (c) Service of a subpoena shall not be subject to this subdivision.



  5.  In assessing compelling need and clear and imminent danger, the court



shall provide written findings of fact,  including  scientific  or  medical



findings,  citing  specific  evidence  in  the  record  which supports each



finding, and shall weigh  the  need  for  disclosure  against  the  privacy



interest  of  the protected individual and the public interest which may be



disserved by disclosure which deters future testing or treatment  or  which



may lead to discrimination.



  6.    An   order  authorizing  disclosure  of  confidential  HIV  related



information shall:



  (a)   limit  disclosure to that information which is necessary to fulfill



the purpose for which the order is granted; and



  (b)   limit disclosure to those persons whose need for the information is



the basis for the order, and specifically  prohibit  redisclosure  by  such



persons  to  any  other  persons,  whether  or  not they are parties to the



action; and



  (c)   to the extent possible consistent with this section, conform to the



provisions of this article; and



  (d)   include  such  other measures as the court deems necessary to limit



any disclosures not authorized by its order.






  S  2785-a.  Court  order  for HIV related testing in certain cases. 1.



Notwithstanding any contrary provision of law or  regulation,  a  state,



county  or local public health officer to whom an order or a consent for



an HIV test is addressed or sent, in accordance with section  390.15  of



the  criminal  procedure  law  or section 347.1 of the family court act,



must cause HIV related testing to be administered to the  subject  named



therein  and,  if  the test is pursuant to court order, must immediately



provide to the court that issued the order a written  report  specifying



the  date  on  which  such  test was completed. Such report to the court



shall not, however, disclose the results of such test. Such officer must



disclose the results of the testing to the victim indicated in the order



or consent and must also disclose the  results  to  the  person  tested,



unless  the  person  tested  has been asked to but declines to authorize



such disclosure to himself or herself.



  2. At the time of communicating the test results to the subject or the



victim, such public health officer shall directly provide the victim and



person  tested  with  (a) counseling or referrals for counseling for the



purposes specified in subdivision five of  section  two  thousand  seven



hundred  eighty-one  of  this article; (b) counseling with regard to HIV



disease and HIV testing in  accordance  with  law  and  consistent  with



subdivision  five  of  section  two thousand seven hundred eighty-one of



this article; and (c) appropriate health care and support  services,  or



referrals  to  such available services.  If at the time of communicating



the test results, the person tested is in the custody of the  department



of correctional services, division for youth, office of mental health or



a local correctional institution, the counseling and  services  required



by  this  subdivision  may  be  provided  by  a  public  health  officer



associated with the county or facility within which the person tested is



confined.



  3.  Unless  inconsistent  with  this  section,  the provisions of this



article regarding the confidentiality  and  disclosure  of  HIV  related



information  shall  apply  to  proceedings conducted pursuant to section



390.15 of the criminal procedure law or  section  347.1  of  the  family



court act.



 


   S  2786.  Rules and regulations; forms; report.  1.  The commissioner



shall promulgate rules and regulations concerning implementation of this



article  for  health facilities, health care providers and other persons



to whom this article is applicable.  The commissioner shall also develop



forms  to  be  used for informed consent for HIV related testing and for



the release of confidential HIV related information  and  materials  for



pre-test   counseling  as  required  by  subdivision  three  of  section



twenty-seven hundred eighty-one  of  this  article,  and  for  post-test



counseling  as  required  by  subdivision  five  of section twenty-seven



hundred eighty-one of this  article.   Persons,  health  facilities  and



health care providers may use forms for informed consent for HIV related



testing, and for the release of  confidential  HIV  related  information



other than those forms developed pursuant to this section, provided that



the person, health facility or health care provider  doing  so  receives



prior  authorization  from  the  commissioner.   All  forms developed or



authorized pursuant to this section shall be  written  in  a  clear  and



coherent  manner  using  words  with  common,  everyday  meanings.   The



commissioner, in consultation with the AIDS institute advisory  council,



shall  promulgate  regulations  to  identify  those  circumstances which



create a significant risk of contracting or transmitting HIV  infection;



provided,  however,  that such regulations shall not be determinative of



any significant risk determined pursuant to paragraph (a) of subdivision



four  of section twenty-seven hundred eighty-two or section twenty-seven



hundred eighty-five of this article.



  2.  (a)   Each  state  agency  authorized  pursuant to this article to



obtain confidential HIV related information shall, in consultation  with



the  department  of  health,  promulgate  regulations:   (1)  to provide



safequards to prevent discrimination, abuse  or  other  adverse  actions



directed  toward  protected individuals; (2)  to prohibit the disclosure



of such information except in accordance with  this  article;   (3)   to



seek  to  protect  individuals  in contact with the protected individual



when  such  contact  creates  a  significant  risk  of  contracting   or



transmitting  HIV infection through the exchange of body fluids, and (4)



to establish criteria for determining when it  is  reasonably  necessary



for  a  provider  of a health or social service or the state agency or a



local government agency to have  or  to  use  confidential  HIV  related



information    for    supervision,    monitoring,    investigation,   or



administration and for determining which employees and  agents  may,  in



the ordinary course of business of the agency or provider, be authorized



to  access  confidential  HIV  related  information  pursuant   to   the



provisions  of paragraphs (l) and (m) of subdivision one and subdivision



six of section twenty-seven hundred  eighty-two  of  this  article;  and



provided  further  that  such  regulations  shall  be promulgated by the



chairperson of the commission of correction  where  disclosure  is  made



pursuant  to  paragraphs  (n)  and  (o)  of  subdivision  one of section



twenty-seven hundred eighty-two of this article.



  (b)   The department of health, in consultation with agencies referred



to in paragraph (a) of this subdivision, shall submit a  report  to  the



legislature  by  December first, nineteen hundred eighty-nine, outlining



the status  and  content  of  such  regulations,  their  effect  on  the



regulated  facilities  and the protected individuals served by them, the



extent to  which  they  conform  with  current  medical  and  scientific



knowledge   on   the   transmissibility   of   HIV  infection,  and  any



recommendations for changes in said regulations.



 


   S  2787.  Separability.  If  any  section,  clause  or provision of this



article shall be deemed by  any  court  of  competent  jurisdiction  to  be



unconstitutional  or ineffective in whole or in part, to the extent that it



is not unconstitutional or ineffective, it shall be valid and effective and



no  other  section,  clause or provision shall on account thereof be deemed



invalid or ineffective.








New York State Assembly
[ Welcome Page ] [ Legislative Information ]