n a costly
and quietly insistent campaign to spread its state religion, Saudi
Arabia has been trying for decades to induce American Muslims to
become followers of the puritanical Islamic sect that sustains the
power of the Saudi royal family.
By building mosques across the country, sending Americans to the
Middle East to be trained as imams and promoting pilgrimages to
Mecca, the Saudis have spent hundreds of millions of dollars in an
effort to stamp their austere version of Islam on the lives of
Muslims in the United States.
That version is called Wahhabism, although the Saudis are loath
to use the term in referring to their proselytizing in this country.
As practiced in Saudi Arabia, Wahhabism denies equal rights to
women, and its teachings have inspired the violent extremism of
Osama bin Laden and the Taliban government that harbors him in
Afghanistan.
"In America, the Saudis don't call it Wahhabism because they
don't want to have all the albatrosses associated with the sect,"
said Earle H. Waugh, a professor of religion at the University of
Alberta, who is the author of several books about Muslims in North
America. "But they have a strong mission tradition, and they have
used their money to export their ideology to America. Wahhabism says
that Islam is the superior religion and must always be so."
Despite all their efforts, the Saudis' approach to Islam appears
not to have found widespread acceptance in the United States and in
fact seems to have faded in popularity here in recent years, perhaps
because it is too rigid for a multiethnic society like America's.
Experts estimate that of the two million American Muslims who attend
mosques regularly, no more than 25 percent, and perhaps many fewer,
adhere to the strictures of Wahhabism.
As the Saudis themselves explain, their beliefs reject aspects of
Western culture that they see as deviating from fundamental
teachings of the Koran. Mingling of the sexes, living in a community
where alcohol is consumed, eating pork and interacting very closely
with non-Muslim society are forbidden.
"A knowledgeable Muslim will find it hard to integrate into a
non- Islamic society of the United States," explained Muhammad
al-Alahmari, a Saudi who is chairman of the Islamic Assembly of
North America, an organization based in Ann Arbor, Mich., that sends
copies of the Koran to prisons and libraries.
About half the group's money, Mr. Alahmari said, comes from the
Saudi government, with the rest coming from private donors, most of
them Saudi.
A number of prominent religious scholars describe Wahhabism as a
particularly rigid minority Islamic sect that is intolerant of other
forms of Islam, unwilling to accommodate other religions and likely
to create a narrow view of the world among its followers.
The sect is named for Muhammad bin Abd al-Wahhab, an 18th-century
clan leader whose descendants helped the Saudi ruling family unify
its kingdom in 1932. Members of the Wahhab family continue to hold
prominent positions in the country.
"It is not a form of Islam that most people from the rest of the
world are comfortable with," said Bruce Lawrence, a professor of
Islamic studies at Duke University and author of "Shattering the
Myth: Islam Beyond Violence" (Princeton University Press, 2000).
"While it does not, in and of itself, promote violence, there are
elements and possibilities in Wahhabism for extremism."
Like many other Saudis in America, Mr. Alahmari does not like to
refer to the brand of Islam that is exported from his country as
Wahhabism. "We don't feel Wahhabism is something different," he
said. "It is a purification of Islam."
An official at the Saudi Embassy in Washington, who for reasons
of personal security spoke only on condition that he not be
identified by name, said it was incorrect and unfair to refer to
Wahhabism as a sect.
"It is chic today to be anti-Saudi," the official said, blaming
Mr. bin Laden, who was born into a wealthy Saudi family, for the
attention that has been focused since Sept. 11 on religious practice
in his country. "We are a puritan system. We believe you have to go
to the fundamentals, but it has nothing to do with being a
sect."
Followers of Wahhabism believe that their faith should be spread
around the world and that they have a special obligation to defend
Islam, with violence if need be, in countries where it is already
well established.
Inside Saudi Arabia, they have insisted that the government not
allow women to drive and that punishment for crimes be imposed
according to the Koran, with amputation of a hand for theft and
beheading for capital offenses.
For all the efforts, Saudi influence appears to have waned in the
last decade. In part, as Mr. Alahmari and several experts said, the
reason is that the Saudi government is in debt and simply does not
have much spare cash to spend on mosques and scholarships in
America.
In addition, many scholars and American Muslims said, the
influence of Wahhabism has faded because its inflexibility is ill
suited to life in the United States and to the multiethnic mix of
American Muslims. About 30 percent of Muslims in this country are
African-Americans, 33 percent are of East Asian origin, and 25
percent are of Arab descent.
"Living in America pushes people into the mainstream," said Dr.
Zahid Bukhari, a fellow at Georgetown University's Center for
Muslim-Christian Understanding. "Muslims in this country are
blending with each other. There is more convergence and more
acceptance of each other's opinion."
In Los Angeles, Levent Akbarut, a Turkish-American Muslim who
sits on the board of an Islamic school, puts it more bluntly:
"Wahhabism is a dynamic from Saudi Arabia that has no relevance in
American life. It is only here because the Saudi government has
tried to export it."
It is difficult to assess the reach of the Saudis in influencing
the religious lives of the estimated six million to seven million
Muslims in this country.
In the 1970's and 80's, when Saudi Arabia was flush with oil
money, the United States experienced a boom in the founding of
mosques. About 57 percent of the country's 1,200 mosques were built
in those years, academics estimate.
Records of the Saudi-controlled Muslim World League show that
during a two-year span in the 1980's, the organization spent about
$10 million in the United States on mosque construction, said Yvonne
Y. Haddad, a professor of the history of Islam at the Georgetown
center.
Mr. Alahmari, the Saudi charity official based in Ann Arbor,
estimates that half the mosques and Islamic schools in the United
States have been built with the help of money from Saudi Arabia. The
Saudi royal family has directly contributed to the construction of a
dozen mosques, including the $8.1 million King Fahd Mosque in Culver
City, Calif.
Although the Saudi Embassy official maintained that "there are
absolutely no strings attached" to Saudi spending, several scholars
and American Muslims said the money had often involved a quid pro
quo.
"At several mosques around Los Angeles, they would dole out money
month by month until something happened that they didn't like, such
as boys and girls mixing together in religious classes," said Mr.
Akbarut, a member of the Islamic Center of Southern California. He
said the Pasadena mosque where he prays had refused money from the
Saudis.
The training of Americans, especially African-Americans, as imams
in Saudi Arabia has also had a clear ideological purpose, said
Faheem Shuaibe, imam at a large, predominantly black mosque in
Oakland, Calif. More than 200 African-American imams have been
trained in Saudi Arabia, he said.
"There was a very deliberate recruitment process by the Saudis,
trying to find black Muslims who had a real potential for Islamic
learning and also for submission to their agenda," said Mr. Shuaibe,
who has frequently traveled to Saudi Arabia. "They taught Islam with
the intent to expand their influence. A principal target was to stop
the indigenous Muslim leadership in America from tinkering with the
religion."
Estimates of the percentage of American Muslims who worship in
mosques that adhere to Wahhabism vary widely. Just as Saudis do not
describe their faith as Wahhabism, conservative imams in America
reject that label for their mosques. Several scholars said they did
not know of a single mosque in this country that identified itself
with the Saudi sect.
Dr. Lawrence, the professor of Islamic studies at Duke, guesses
that about one-fourth of the two million American Muslims who
regularly attend mosques "fall under the Wahhabi umbrella."
Other scholars say the percentage is much lower and steadily
falling.
"It is very insignificant," said Dr. Haddad, the Islam historian
at Georgetown. "The Saudi influence weakened considerably in the
1990's, as many believers stopped being Muslims living in America
and became American Muslims."