REGIONAL ACCOUNTING STUDY

The West Pacific Rim

Prepared by Pei-Hua Tu, Ya-Ting Chang and Sookyoung Lee

 

General

Economy

Accounting profession

Financial reporting

Accounting standards

Details for six countries

 


General

Location

The term 'West Pacific Rim' used in this report refers primarily to the countries which border the western rim of the Pacific Ocean, namely Japan, South Korea, China, and Taiwan, and most of the countries of the Association of South-East Asian Nations (ASEAN-4), namely Malaysia, the Philippines, Singapore and Thailand.

From Japan, in the north of the region, to the southern border of China is referred to as Northeast Asia, and the countries south of Hong Kong are classified as Southeast Asia.

 

Brief modern history

Northeast Asia

Northeast Asia aroused keen competition among the major powers of the world, since the heyday of western imperialism.

Japan asserted its dominant position in the Korean peninsula and northeastern part of China.

The United States involved itself in the region against the aggressive designs of other imperialists, notably Japan.

The region became the center of the triangular relationship that existed among the three major powers, the United States, the former Russia and China, each of which had extensive interests and commitments in the region.

The presence of Japan, with its vast economic reserves, added to the complexities of the region.

Southeast Asia

The ethnic and cultural patterns of Southeast Asia are marked by their extreme diversity.

National institutions were diverse in form and substance, ranging from monarchy to military autocracy.

The entire region except Thailand was under colonial domination until the end of World War II.

The post-war history of Southeast Asia evolved around the struggle for independence.

 

Country description

Country

Area (000 sq. km)

Population

(1996)

Language

Currency

Capital

China

9561

1,223.9m

Mandarin

Reminbi

Beijing

Japan

378

125.8m

Japanese

Yen

Tokyo

Malaysia

330

20.1m

Bahasa malaysia

Ringgit

Federal Territory of Kuala Lumpur

Philippines

300

73.3m

Pilipino, English, Spanish

Peso

Manila

Singapore

0.6

3.01m

English, Chinese, Malay, Tamil

Singapore dollar

Singapore City

South Korea

98

45.5m

Korean

Won

Seoul

Taiwan

36

21.5m

Mandarin, Taiwanese

New Taiwan dollar

Taipei

Thailand

514

60.2m

Thai

Baht

Bangkok

 

[Top of page]


Economy

The center of international economic dynamism that used to be in the Mediterranean in the distant past was overtaken by the Atlantic in the past two hundred years, but seems to have moved to the Asia-Pacific region since the mid-1960s.

The West Pacific Rim is often described as a 'miracle economy' flourishing in the 'Pacific Century'. With one exception, the economics of the area have deservedly earned a reputation as fast growing and dynamic.

 

The economies: relative size and diversity

This region is rather diverse and complex. The table shown below provides an indication of the diversity of the West Pacific economies by focusing on per capita GNP, and a 'market share' measure of GDP (expressed both in terms of regional and world GDP).

 

Country

Per capita GNP 1993 (US$)

% of total regional GDP 1990

% of world GDP 1989

China

490

8.2

2.3

Japan

31,490

66.8

17.7

Malaysia

3,140

0.9

1.0

Philippines

850

1.0

0.4

Singapore

19,850

0.8

0.2

South Korea

7,660

5.4

1.1

Taiwan

10,215

3.3

0.8

Thailand

2,110

1.8

0.3

Source: Ialam & Chowdhury (1997)

 

Economic growth and structural change: recent performance

As a group, the West Pacific economies have grown well above the world average, thus confirming the popular perception of the dynamism of the region. From 1971 to1992, the newly industrializing economies (NIEs), ASEAN-4 and China taken as a collective entity grew at 7.7 per cent, while the growth rate for the world economy over the same period was 2.9 per cent. As noted, the World Bank (1993) has compiled a list of the twenty fastest growing economics in the world using per capita GDP growth rate over the 1965-85 period. All of the West Pacific economics, with the conspicuous exception of the Philippines, belong to this exclusive list of the 'top twenty'.

The rapid growth of the West Pacific economies has been supported by very high savings and investment ratios, as shown in the followings:

Gross domestic saving rates (per cent of GDP), 1981-95

Country

1981-90

1991-93

1994

1995

China

34.4

34.5

35.2

35.5

Japan*

32.1**

33.6

31.4

30.7

Malaysia

33.0

34.6

39.4

38.7

Philippines

22.3

16.0

15.0

16.0

Singapore

42.6

46.6

45.0

45.0

South Korea

32.0

35.7

34.5

34.3

Taiwan

32.9

27.3

27.3

27.6

Thailand

27.2

35.5

38.9

40.1

Source: Ialam & Chowdhury (1997) (except for Japan)

*Source: International Monetary Fund (1997)

**1983-1990

 

Gross domestic investment rates (per cent of GDP), 1981-95

Country

1981-90

1991-93

1994

1995

China

32.1

35.7

36.2

36.0

Japan*

29.3

30.9

28.7

28.5

Malaysia

34.7

33.9

34.5

35.0

Philippines

21.9

22.3

25.0

26.4

Singapore

42.2

40.1

41.5

42.0

Korea

30.5

36.6

33.8

33.0

Taiwan

22.6

23.6

26.1

26.6

Thailand

30.6

41.7

44.1

45.1

Source: Ialam & Chowdhury (1997) (except for Japan)

*Source: International Monetary Fund (1997)

**1983-1990

 

 

Overall, the West Pacific region reduced its dependence on the U.S. market in the later part of the 1980s. In addition, the share of intra-regional trade rose significantly after 1985.

 

The labor market

Labor market performance in West Pacific region has been epitomized by rapid employment expansion and growth of real wages.

 

[Top of page]


Accounting profession

The development of a national accountancy profession depends on the type of financial system in the country. The size of accountancy profession also depends on the extent to which it is composed of accountants working in commerce and industry as well as professional accountancy firms. Among those countries, except for China, the oldest and largest pubic accountancy body is found in the Philippines. The size and founding date of public accountancy bodies for those countries are summarized as follows:

 

Country

Body

Founding date

Approximate membership (thousand) 1996-1997

China

Chinese Institute of Certified Public Accountants

 

124

Japan

Japanese Institute of Certified Public Accountant

1948

15

Malaysia

Malaysian Association of Certified Public Accountant;

Malaysian Institute of Accountants

1958

 

1967

5

 

9

Philippines

Philippines Institute of Certified Public Accountants

1929

23 (1990)

Singapore

Institute of Certified Public Accountants of Singapore

1963

9

South Korea

Korean Institute of Certified Public Accountant

1954

4

Taiwan

National Federation of CPA Associations of the Republic of China

1946

3

Thailand

Institute of Certified Accountants and Auditors of Thailand

1948

N/A

Major source: Cooke & Parker (1994)

 

[Top of page]


Financial reporting

Diversity is also found in the styles of the corporate financial reporting for the countries in the region. The relative importance of different sources of influence on financial reporting of each country is summarized as follows:

 

 

Company law or commercial code

Tax law

Stock exchange requirements

Regulatory body

Accounting standards body

China

/

/

N/A

/

/

Japan

/

/

/

x

/

Malaysia

/

x

+

x

/

Philippines

+

x

+

/

/

Singapore

/

x

+

x

/

South Korea

/

/

x

/

/

Taiwan

/

/

x

+

/

Thailand

/

x

/

+

+

Key: / very important; + of some importance; x of little important.

Source: Cooke & Parker (1994) (except for China)

 

It is noted that the company law or commercial code is an important source of rules on financial reporting in all countries. The tax law is relative less important except in Japan, South Korea, and Taiwan. In Japan and Thailand, stock exchange requirements are important. In the Philippines, the financial reporting is well supported by a regulatory framework. In all countries, an accounting standard-setting body is important.

 

[Top of page]


Accounting standards

There is great diversity found in the accounting standard setting for the countries of the West Pacific Rim.

The influence of accounting standards of other countries and those of the International Accounting Standards Committee (IASC) on the national accounting standards for selected countries are summarized as follows:

China: IASs are adapted to local conditions.

Japan: The accounting standards are not much influenced by foreign standards or IASs although Japan is the founder member of the IASC.

South Korea: The accounting standards are influenced by those in the United States. IASs are taken into account.

Malaysia: IASs are regarded as a model of accounting standards and have been adapted to local conditions. Influenced by accounting standards in the UK, Australia, and the United States.

Philippines: Accounting standards in the Philippines are modeled on U.S. standards. IASs are taken into account.

Singapore: IASs are regarded as a model of accounting standards and have been adapted to local conditions. Influenced by accounting standards in the UK, Australia, and the United States.

Taiwan: Accounting standards in Taiwan are mainly influenced by U.S. accounting standards. IASs are used only for reference.

Thailand: The Thai accounting standards tend to be Anglo-American in style but seem to be particularly influenced by U.S. accounting standards. They also take into account of IASs.

 

It is said that Japanese and Korean accounting is similar to that in Germany and France, while the accounting in most of the other countries in the region is similar to that in the United Kingdom and the United States. The U.S. accounting also has great influence on the region after World War II, particularly in Japan, Korea, and Taiwan.

 

The table shown below summarizes the accounting standard-setting bodies of the West Pacific Rim countries.

Country

Body

China

Ministry of Finance

Japan

Business Accounting Deliberation Council (of the Ministry of Finance)

Malaysia

Accounting and Auditing Standards Committee (of MACPA and MIA)

Philippines

Accounting Standards Committee (autonomous body set up by the PICPA and supported by regulatory agencies)

Singapore

Accounting Standards Committee (of ICPAS)

South Korea

Accounting System Deliberation Committee (of the SEC)

Taiwan

Financial Accounting Standards Committee (of the Accounting Research & Development Foundation)

Thailand

Committee on Financial Accounting Standards (of ICAAT)

 

[Top of page]


Details for six countries

 

China

Japan

Singapore

South Korea

Taiwan

The Philippines

 

[Top of page]


References

Cooke, T. E. and R. H. Parker (ed.). Financial Reporting in the West Pacific Rim, Routledge, London, 1994.

Ialam, Iyanatul and Anis Chowdhury. Asia-Pacific Economies: a survey, Routledge, London and New York, 1997.

Shibusawa, Masahide. Japan and the Asian Pacific Region-Profile of Change, Croom Helm for the Royal Institute of International Affairs, London, 1984.

World Economic Outlook, October 1997, International Monetary Fund, Washington, DC, 1997.